Need feedback on game capture - ancient thread alarm

C

ColterTV

Member
Re: Need feedback on a new version of game capture - updated

Ramten you can type the number instead of using the drop down. Not sure which number is optimal in test7, I guess Jim will tell us soon :)

I noticed that test7 has delay and a timer to know how much we've been streaming, nice !

Jim, makes sense to add the profile name in the status window too? Just to be sure where we are streaming to :)
 
B

Bensam123

Member
Re: Need feedback on a new version of game capture - updated

I'll write up a more comprehensive version of my opinion on OBS, but using the built in game capture this is what I found.

Comparing built in OBS to DXtory, objectively speaking OBS gives a huge boost to FPS. It's almost as if it has little to no impact on the actual fps.

Subjectively there appears to be 1-2 frames of intermittent input latency. I don't know how to measure this, but I can definitely feel it. Sometimes it's not present, other times it ads a sort of 'bluriness' to the picture in high action scenes for lack of a better way to describe it. It gives me the start of a mild headache as well.

So while OBS offers better FPS, it seems to add some sort of latency to the mix. It almost feels like a buffer is added when it's on, like triple buffering for vsync.
 
M

Muf

Forum Moderator
Re: Need feedback on a new version of game capture - updated

simondoto said:
What is the 'Unlock higher FPS rates' option?
Click to expand...
It allows you to enter a framerate higher than 60 into the FPS box.
 
S

simondoto

New Member
Re: Need feedback on a new version of game capture - updated

Thanks Muf. I noticed there's no option to show the mousecursor in game capture (test7)..
 
K

kryty

New Member
Re: Need feedback on a new version of game capture - updated

Tried out the Test7 with Quake Live. Change of resolution (vid_restart) = crash and closed the game = crash. But the browser stayed at QL site. When went back to practice game after that, QL crashed with OBS closed, giving following error:

QuakeLive caused an Integer Divide by Zero (0xc0000094) in module
C:\Apuohjelmat\OBS Daily\plugins\GraphicsCapture\GraphicsCaptureHook.dll
at 0023:629b3b8b.
 
L

Lain

Forum Admin
Lain
Forum Moderator
Developer
Re: Need feedback on a new version of game capture - updated

Well, that's a rather hilarious error. Guess I better check to see where I'm doing divisions.

Anyway, closing the app/game while streaming, as well as resolution changes in the game and sometimes alt-tabbing is still somewhat buggy. I'm working on trying to get them stabilized at the moment.

As stated in the original post, mouse currently doesn't capture but I'll get it in
 
S

simondoto

New Member
Re: Need feedback on a new version of game capture - updated

Got this crash today when I tried to add a bitmap to an active stream.
EDIT: Ths only appears when I browse to My Pictures folder in My Documents. Maybe a thumbnail related error?

Code: 
OBS has encountered an unhandled exception and has terminated. If you are able to reproduce this crash, please submit this crash report on the forums at
http://www.obsproject.com/ - include the contents of this crash log and the
minidump .dmp file (if available) as well as your regular OBS log files and
a description of what you were doing at the time of the crash.

This crash appears to have occured in the 'c:\windows\syswow64\kernelbase.dll' module.

**** UNHANDLED EXCEPTION: e0000001
Fault address: 766EC41F (c:\windows\syswow64\kernelbase.dll)
OBS version: Open Broadcaster Software v0.445a [pre-release 2]
Windows version: 6.1 (Build 7601) Service Pack 1

Crashing thread stack trace:
Stack    EIP      Arg0     Arg1     Arg2     Arg3     Address
1DBDE394 766EC41F E0000001 00000000 00000001 1DBDE40C kernelbase.dll!0x766ec41f
1DBDE3EC 54769105 C00CE508 3D35793A 1E59B1B0 1E59BBA4 msxml6.dll!0x54769105
1DBDE40C 54766A4F 3D357976 00000000 1E59BB50 00000000 msxml6.dll!0x54766a4f
1DBDE444 546F5035 1E59B1B0 3D3579B2 00000000 1E59BB50 msxml6.dll!0x546f5035
1DBDE478 546F4F63 00000000 00000000 00000000 1CF1C4E8 msxml6.dll!0x546f4f63
1DBDE4BC 5470D309 1CF1C4E8 3D357846 1CF1C4E8 1E59BB50 msxml6.dll!0x5470d309
1DBDE514 5470D39E 54ABA1D3 1CF1C4E8 3D3578B6 1DBDE5CC msxml6.dll!0x5470d39e
1DBDE548 5470D423 1CF1C4E8 0000000D 159E2BAB 1CF1C4E8 msxml6.dll!0x5470d423
1DBDE5B8 159E59D6 1CF19400 1CD8D070 00000001 1CF8A0B8 windowscodecsext.dll!0x159e59d6
1DBDE63C 159E56EF 1BE9274C 1CF8A0B8 1CD8D070 00000001 windowscodecsext.dll!0x159e56ef
1DBDE6D0 705D1471 00881C70 705A8C08 1CD8D070 00000001 windowscodecs.dll!0x705d1471
1DBDE710 705F2300 1CD8D084 00000003 1DBDE7B4 00000000 windowscodecs.dll!0x705f2300
1DBDE784 705CFC6A 1DBDE8C8 00000001 00000000 00000003 windowscodecs.dll!0x705cfc6a
1DBDE7E8 705CFA42 00000001 1CD93010 1DBDE890 1CD93038 windowscodecs.dll!0x705cfa42
1DBDE824 705CF5FF 1599117A 1DBDEFEC 1CEABD60 1DBDEFDC windowscodecs.dll!0x705cf5ff
1DBDE86C 705D1841 1CD93038 15991170 1DBDEFDC 1DBDEFDC windowscodecs.dll!0x705d1841
1DBDED6C 159B22D5 15991170 00000001 00000000 1DBDEFDC photometadatahandler.dll!0x159b22d5
1DBDED8C 1599D8CA 15991170 00000001 00000000 1DBDEFDC photometadatahandler.dll!0x1599d8ca
1DBDEFBC 159B2258 159A1ED0 1DBDF048 00000000 00000001 photometadatahandler.dll!0x159b2258
1DBDF000 159B1CB2 159A1ED0 1DBDF048 00000000 00000000 photometadatahandler.dll!0x159b1cb2
1DBDF018 159B2187 1DBDF5C4 3D3641EE 1CD93010 1CD93010 photometadatahandler.dll!0x159b2187
1DBDF054 159A739C 1CF1C588 1CD93038 159836A8 1DBDF5C4 photometadatahandler.dll!0x159a739c
1DBDF088 705F039D 1CD93038 159836A8 1DBDF5C4 3D36449A windowscodecs.dll!0x705f039d
1DBDF594 1599B99D 00000002 54B1E4FC 54B1E458 1599D948 photometadatahandler.dll!0x1599b99d
1DBDF5FC 1599BBDF 54B1E460 00000000 00000000 1DBDF664 photometadatahandler.dll!0x1599bbdf
1DBDF624 1599DC03 54B1E460 00873900 1DBDF8B8 1CF1C550 photometadatahandler.dll!0x1599dc03
1DBDF638 725C75A1 54B1E460 00873900 1DBDF8B8 00000000 propsys.dll!Ordinal424+0x55
1DBDF66C 74F6144F 00873900 1DBDF8B8 00000000 00000000 shell32.dll!0x74f6144f
1DBDF68C 74F61428 1CF1C550 00873900 1DBDF8B8 00000001 shell32.dll!0x74f61428
1DBDF6A4 725C75A1 1CF1C550 00873900 1DBDF8B8 00000000 propsys.dll!Ordinal424+0x55
1DBDF6D8 725C7A89 00873900 1DBDF8B8 00000000 00000000 propsys.dll!Ordinal424+0x53d
1DBDF728 725C79E3 54B0EAA8 00873900 1DBDF8B8 00000001 propsys.dll!Ordinal424+0x497
1DBDF740 725C75A1 54B0EAA8 00873900 1DBDF8B8 00000000 propsys.dll!Ordinal424+0x55
1DBDF774 725C7A89 00873900 1DBDF8B8 00000000 00000000 propsys.dll!Ordinal424+0x53d
1DBDF7C4 725C79E3 54AAD340 00873900 1DBDF8B8 1DBDF8C8 propsys.dll!Ordinal424+0x497
1DBDF7DC 725C75A1 54AAD340 00873900 1DBDF8B8 00000000 propsys.dll!Ordinal424+0x55
1DBDF810 725C74CE 00873900 1DBDF8B8 00000000 00000000 propsys.dll!Ordinal400+0x821
1DBDF850 725C741E 00873900 1DBDF8B8 00000000 00000000 propsys.dll!Ordinal400+0x771
1DBDF888 725C73B2 54AAD2E8 00873900 1DBDF8B8 00DFC148 propsys.dll!Ordinal400+0x705
1DBDF8A0 5B138A6D 54AAD2E8 1DBDF934 00000000 54B46C08 searchfolder.dll!0x5b138a6d
1DBDF8E0 5B1389B3 00000000 1DBDF9AC 10000000 80000000 searchfolder.dll!0x5b1389b3
1DBDF934 5B12E2C8 1DBDF9AC 80004005 54B46BA0 1DBDFA04 searchfolder.dll!0x5b12e2c8
1DBDF958 5B12E1BB 54B46BA0 1DBDF9AC 75D23472 54B0CD8C searchfolder.dll!0x5b12e1bb
1DBDF974 5B12E97C 54B0CD8C 00000000 00000000 00000001 searchfolder.dll!0x5b12e97c
1DBDF990 5B12D60F 000002A2 54B0CD8C 00000000 54BB9ED8 searchfolder.dll!0x5b12d60f
1DBDF9CC 5B134B52 00000000 000002A2 54BB9ED8 5B124850 searchfolder.dll!0x5b134b52
1DBDFA04 5B128522 00000000 1DBDFACC 75D243C0 54B3CE08 searchfolder.dll!0x5b128522
1DBDFA40 5B159A48 54B3CE08 00000000 00000000 1B34FD04 searchfolder.dll!0x5b159a48
1DBDFA4C 75D243C0 1B34FD04 1DBDFB18 770C9EF2 1B34FD04 shlwapi.dll!0x75d243c0
1DBDFAD4 75E433AA 1B34FD04 69BFCEE3 00000000 00000000 kernel32.dll!0x75e433aa
1DBDFAE0 770C9EF2 75D242ED 1B34FD04 00000000 00000000 ntdll.dll!0x770c9ef2
1DBDFB20 770C9EC5 75D242ED 1B34FD04 00000000 00000000 ntdll.dll!0x770c9ec5

A minidump was saved to C:\Users\YE\AppData\Roaming\OBS\crashDumps\OBSCrashDump2012-11-20_1.dmp.
Please include this file when posting a crash report.
 
L

Lain

Forum Admin
Lain
Forum Moderator
Developer
Re: Need feedback on a new version of game capture - updated

simondoto - will check it out, thank you very much for the report.

New version, test9 - I have been attempting to get rid of more of the alt-tab issues, as well as issues where it will fail to reacquire when lost, and restarting the game and such. Please let me know if this helps with the problem if any of you were experiencing those problems before.
 
I

idontknow017

New Member
Re: Need feedback on a new version of game capture - updated

Test9 - had the same lag issues as test3; that is, in-game it was fine but on the stream it paused every 2 seconds. I retried test7 afterwards to make sure it wasn't my internet (and it wasn't). Stream using test9

Also, I didn't have any alt-tab issues with either version.
 
L

Lain

Forum Admin
Lain
Forum Moderator
Developer
Re: Need feedback on a new version of game capture - updated

Ah, hm, yea, that stream did not turn out so good. Seems like you're dropping tons of frames. So you say that test7 was better for your frame dropping issues?
 
I

idontknow017

New Member
Re: Need feedback on a new version of game capture - updated

Jim said:
Ah, hm, yea, that stream did not turn out so good. Seems like you're dropping tons of frames. So you say that test7 was better for your frame dropping issues?
Click to expand...

Yup, test7 didn't have any frame dropping issues.
 
E

EmilosG

New Member
Re: Need feedback on a new version of game capture - updated

That might have been why my stream was lagging greatly on the test 9, i made another topic on it, in problems and bugs! :) hope this gets fixed in 10, or just tell me if i should use 7!
 
S

simondoto

New Member
Re: Need feedback on a new version of game capture - updated

idontknow017 said:
Test9 - had the same lag issues as test3; that is, in-game it was fine but on the stream it paused every 2 seconds. I retried test7 afterwards to make sure it wasn't my internet (and it wasn't). Stream using test9

Also, I didn't have any alt-tab issues with either version.
Click to expand...

Did you by any chance change the buffer size when upgrading to test9?
I had the same result as your link when i put 0 as buffer size

Been streaming for a couple of hours now and no frame drops with test9, however I did have frame drops on test7. Could be my bandwidth load making frames drop but worth mentioning.
 
X

Xerouz

Member
Re: Need feedback on a new version of game capture - updated

I'm still having a problem with the game capture causing Starcraft II to crash. I can alt+tab out of Starcraft, but as soon as I tab back in, it crashes the game. This is using test 9 and happens every time.
 
M

mmdollar

New Member
Re: Need feedback on a new version of game capture - updated

After around 6-7 hours of streaming Assassin's Creed III with Test9 I had perfect ingame performance (there was no difference when I streamed and not regarding my fps ingame) video stream was nice too (when I viewed the video there were no frames dropping or at least not that I can see) there was a complain from one of my viewers regarding stuttering video on the stream but that could have been his connection since none of my other viewers complained. Overall great work this works a lot better than capturing desktop regarding performance, here is a video with Test9.
 
T

T6kke

New Member
Re: Need feedback on a new version of game capture - updated

OBS and Hawken crashed while the game started loading the map.

Code: 
OBS has encountered an unhandled exception and has terminated. If you are able to
reproduce this crash, please submit this crash report on the forums at
http://www.obsproject.com/ - include the contents of this crash log and the
minidump .dmp file (if available) as well as your regular OBS log files and
a description of what you were doing at the time of the crash.

This crash appears to have occured in the 'd:\obs_0445a_capture_32bit_test9\plugins\graphicscapture.dll' module.

**** UNHANDLED EXCEPTION: c0000005
Fault address: 655826A3 (d:\obs_0445a_capture_32bit_test9\plugins\graphicscapture.dll)
OBS version: Open Broadcaster Software v0.445a [pre-release 2]
Windows version: 6.1 (Build 7601) Service Pack 1

Crashing thread stack trace:
Stack    EIP      Arg0     Arg1     Arg2     Arg3     Address
003FF170 655826A3 65582420 001A037A 00000402 00000000 graphicscapture.dll!0x655826a3
003FF1A8 74996D3A 008521FC 65582420 001A037A 00000402 user32.dll!0x74996d3a
003FF220 749977C4 65582420 00000000 003FF344 013064ED user32.dll!0x749977c4
003FF280 7499788A 003FF2A4 15289520 FFFFFFFE 00000000 user32.dll!0x7499788a
003FF290 013064ED 76F73CC3 776DFA5F FFFFFFFE 008047AC obs.exe!0x13064ed
003FF3A4 76F73C94 776DFA5F FFFFFFFE 008047AC 00800000 ntdll.dll!0x76f73c94
003FF3A8 76F73CC3 76F73CEE 00000440 00000448 008301EA ntdll.dll!0x76f73cc3
003FF47C 76F73CC3 00000440 00000448 008301EA 008301E8 ntdll.dll!0x76f73cc3
003FF480 76F73CEE FFFFFFFF 76F5FBCA FFFFFFFE 0139616A ntdll.dll!0x76f73cee
003FF4A8 74CFEFEB FFFFFFFF 00000024 003FF500 00000004 kernelbase.dll!0x74cfefeb
003FF4EC 76F79D6C 2C42AF6D 01423850 00000001 012F0000 ntdll.dll!0x76f79d6c
003FF50C 74B48853 00000000 00000000 00000000 15289520 kernel32.dll!0x74b48853
003FF740 013A467E 012F0000 00000000 0080386B 00000001 obs.exe!0x13a467e
003FF758 0138AD32 7EFDE000 003FF82C 76F79EF2 7EFDE000 obs.exe!0x138ad32
003FF7E8 74B433AA 7EFDE000 776DF60B 00000000 00000000 kernel32.dll!0x74b433aa
003FF7F4 76F79EF2 0138AD9D 7EFDE000 00000000 00000000 ntdll.dll!0x76f79ef2
003FF834 76F79EC5 0138AD9D 7EFDE000 00000000 00000000 ntdll.dll!0x76f79ec5

A minidump was saved to C:\Users\Martin\AppData\Roaming\OBS\crashDumps\OBSCrashDump2012-11-21_1.dmp.
Please include this file when posting a crash report.
 
L

Lain

Forum Admin
Lain
Forum Moderator
Developer
Re: Need feedback on a new version of game capture - updated

T6kke - Yea, I know of that bug, trying to see if I can get it fixed.
 
D

dwskillz

New Member
Re: Need feedback on a new version of game capture - updated

idontknow017 said:
Jim said:
Ah, hm, yea, that stream did not turn out so good. Seems like you're dropping tons of frames. So you say that test7 was better for your frame dropping issues?
Click to expand...

Yup, test7 didn't have any frame dropping issues.
Click to expand...

i was having the same issues with dropped frames but the new test10 drops nothing.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
Top