So I accidently opened CinebenchR23. They changed up the scoring with 2024. Good news, your scores look better, a little low but not dreadful. 96 for the single core is good but the multi-core should be 1600. That's telling me the CPU is getting throttled when it's running maxed out. Is it air, AIO, or custom loop?
I wasn't throttling. My fans were at 100% and the temps were low the whole time. However, you may have just helped me solve my issue and for that I am so thankful!
When you said I may be throttling it made me think to open HwInfo64 and give it a look and one of my sticks of ram is not registering and has become faulty because it's only showing 32 of 64 GB, and it says "Single-Channel" instead of "dual-channel" for the 2 that are there so maybe I just need to buy a new ram stick!! :) I tried to re-seat the RAM and tried it in different slots, but it seems like it's a goner. I guess it must have just died over the last few weeks or something. Thank you so much for your help!
Tl;dr CHECK HWinfo64, look at your RAM speeds and CPU speeds! If your RAM shows weird stuff, check it out!!
I'll update this post when I've gotten new RAM to replace this faulty stick and I'll be able to tell everyone if that's the solution.
I'm 99% sure we figured it out though, and for that I appreciate you all so much!