Question / Help Something about HD.

shardey

New Member
So i heard that to stream in HD i need new monitor cuz one that i have now resolution is 1280x1024.

Will i be able to stream in 720p or so with Asus Serie VK 191, 19 inch? Can someone tell me?
 

bart2712

Member
you should be able to...720p is 1280x720, which is a resolution much lower than your monitors native resolution.

Of course also partially depends on your capture card, if youre using one.
 

dodgepong

Administrator
Community Helper
As bart said, you monitor can already stream 720p. However, to do that you have to either

* Play the game in a 720p window in the middle of your screen in Windowed mode, or
* Play the the game taking up the full screen, but fill in the black bars with other content in OBS

The question here isn't whether you can stream in HD, it's whether you can stream in a 16:9 resolution and have it not have black bars. You can either change your game to be a 16:9 resolution (option A above), or embrace the black bars and fill them with extra content (such as stream chat, webcam, slide show, or something else).

Or you can just live with a 5:4 stream.
 

shardey

New Member
So if i dont want any problems like black bars etc i need monitor which max resolution is in 16:9 ratio, am i right? Such as 1280x720 or 1366x768, 1600x900 etc?
 

XeiZ

Member
"yes" but even if you stream in 16:9, people with 16:10 and others will get black bars.
 

shardey

New Member
XeiZ said:
"yes" but even if you stream in 16:9, people with 16:10 and others will get black bars.

So i got 16:10 right now and when i'm watching ppl with 720p stream i don't see these bars. So can you explain?
 

paibox

heros in an halfshel
If you're not fullscreening the stream on your 16:10 monitor (using a 16:10 resolution on said monitor), or if the player is 16:9 (the Twitch player is 16:9 by default), you will not get black bars while watching a 1280x720 stream.
 

shardey

New Member
Ok, just to make sure and finish this thread. If i get 1366x768 monitor i'll be able to stream without these huge black bars on both sides? Cuz now it's like 1/4 black bar 1/2 stream 1/4 black bar or something(i've read that new monitor is needed to remove that bars). That was actually the point, but i asked shitty questions instead of get to it instantly. Just tell me yes and you can close this topic.
 

dodgepong

Administrator
Community Helper
The black bars shouldn't be *that* big with a 16:10 resolution...Just small bars on the sides.

Can you link to an example video?
 

dodgepong

Administrator
Community Helper
OK, so you're not running the game in a 16:10 resolution but 4:3.

Then yeah, you need a 16:9 monitor to play the game in 16:9 with no black bars, and then consequently stream to twitch in the same aspect ratio.
 

dodgepong

Administrator
Community Helper
I'm not sure how good or bad that monitor is, but it is a good resolution. 1920x1080 ("Full HD") will be the main resolution you'll want to look at.
 

Krazy

Town drunk
I'm really confused as to why people care so much about black bars. It literally does not matter if they are there or not. You'll be hard pressed to find someone who watches streams saying "Ew, black bars, I'm never gonna watch this horrible stream." Picture quality and video smoothness are infinitely more important.
 

FerretBomb

Active Member
Krazy, I've seen a few people comment about a stream being low-quality due to the letterboxing, actually. Filling the screen is important too. Whether it's with the game, a frame image, webcam, chatbox... actually having content to fill the 16:9 has pretty much become one of the standard earmarks for a professional-looking stream. And 16:9 is the de-facto resolution as in non-fullscreen, the Twitch video window is letterboxed to that as well.
 

dodgepong

Administrator
Community Helper
Exactly...you can stream the game in a non-16:9 resolution and fill the black bars with other content, such as the chat or a webcam. I do agree, though, that people freak out about letterboxing way too much. Personally I wouldn't buy a new monitor just so I could stream a game in 16:9.
 

Kharay

Member
shardey said:
http://www.asus.com/Monitors_Projectors/VS229HR/#overview

Will this one be good?
Personally, for gaming I wouldn't go with that one, I'd go with something like this instead:

http://www.samsung.com/us/computer/moni ... S/ZA-specs

In particular, the response time on the one you picked seems a bit on the high end for gaming. It may cause ghosting at high framerates. For gaming you really want the response time as low as possible for the clearest possible image.
 

Xphome

Member
Kharay said:
shardey said:
http://www.asus.com/Monitors_Projectors/VS229HR/#overview

Will this one be good?
Personally, for gaming I wouldn't go with that one, I'd go with something like this instead:

http://www.samsung.com/us/computer/moni ... S/ZA-specs

In particular, the response time on the one you picked seems a bit on the high end for gaming. It may cause ghosting at high framerates. For gaming you really want the response time as low as possible for the clearest possible image.

My monitor has 5ms response time and it's fine for gaming.
 
Top