Question / Help Distorted recordings for certain games

Hellmann

New Member
The part that is technically not about the problem:
Hello beautiful people of this forum, i am quite new to all this obs business and the last few months i have been getting accustomed to the program getting down the settings that work best for me and have been recording some random footage for shits and giggles all throughout this time. I have never had problems with it before and when i felt comfortable with the program (and myself) a few days ago i just gathered all my bravery and tried to start my own youtube channel like i have been dreaming about a long time.

Needless to say i could really apprechiate your peoples help, as at this point i have lost 4hours and 30 minutes of great footage to this problem that i cant find anywhere on google.
I would really wish i didnt have to hope everytime i want to record content for my small channel that the gamplay is not ruined. I really need your help

Getting to the problem:
Pc specs:
Nvidia gtx 1660 ti
Amd ryzen 5 3600
16gb ram


Most Recent Log file
Video Example of the menitoned "distortion"

tldr:
No problem ever, record game, obs closes during recording, creates no crashlog, menu and cutscenes play normal game footage distorted, try diffrent game, same problem, log of the recording says recording terminated due to the game beeing closed- cannot provide logs because of obs reinstall, record "diffrent game" from before, problem seems fixxed, today record cs:go again no problem- then record another game tonight- distortion is back menu clear but gameplay unusable.

Unecessarily in depth description of the Problem:

As i said i have recorded many hours of footage without problems, and the last few days i actually started recording and editing footage seriously- i got as far as uploading two videos on youtube, one video- unedited 1hour 45 minutes, the other 39 minutes also unedited- pretty recent games, one of them the resident evil 3 demo that came out. All without a problem, but yesterday i started running into trouble:

I wanted to record a somewhat older game called call of juarez just to throw out some fast fun content, recorded 40 minutes- close the game to stop the recording, but obs was already closed, the file only 18 minutes long. Obs didnt create a crash log so i assume it closed itself for some reason.

I record in .ts format, just because i falsely understood one day sony vegas cannot open mp4 or mkv, and just stuck with it after i learned better and never had a problem with it- and the files are as far as i have noticed not easily corrupted- but when i try to play the 18 minute video the gameplay part itself is strangely distorted and unusable.
The menu and cutscenes are normal and watchable as usual,
but as soon as it goes into the game everything is unwatchable- Me assuming obs dropped the ball re-record the gameplay again 40 minutes, afterwards same thing. Obs closed, video file 10ish minutes short, no crashlog, i then assumed it must be because of the game, and switch to the first game i recorded (kingdom come deliverance)and uploaded before without problems wanting to make a part 2- play for 2hours 30 minutes, close the game after- same thing, Obs closed itself 7 minutes in, game footage strangely distorted again no crash log.

So i check the normal logs for the footage, and in those it only states along the lines that the recording was terminated due to the game supposedly having gotten closed, only i didnt tab out or anything of that sort, same thing for the other 2 recording attempts for the other game before.
I am sorry i cannot provide logs for these instances
, as i talked to a friend about the problem and he just said i should reinstall the program, and thats what i did.

I then to check- if everything was ok recording a bit of Kingdom come deliverance again, knowing it recorded normally before the incident, and everything was normal. Then today i tried to fiddle around with call of juarez again seeing if i can capture it with a diffrent capture mode, none of which worked always the same distortion problem in the game itself, and i said to myself it must be the game.
Afterwards to make sure the game didnt destroy obs like i assumed it did before, i went to record 20 minutes of counterstrike global offensive, just because i´ve been recording that for fun before without ever running into issues and- everything was good.

Just now i then regained my confidence- and went to record a gameplay for a random horror game i got on steam one day, just to produce some more content for my super small channel- i go to menu put all the settings right, while recording for test purposes, recheck with obs, all good no distort. And after that go do my cheesy intro and play the game for about 40 minutes- i check the recording and again i see the menu all good, so i remux the recording and want to watch a small portion of the video forward past the menu- the distortion is back.
The log i provided is for this recording,
i will also provide a short video showing the problem above as its hard to describe, distortion is not the right word- i would describe it as utterly ruined.



 

Hellmann

New Member
What i noticed just now after the editing time on the post ran out, after importing the remuxed file into sony vegas the distortion disappears, but there is a problem with the fps, everything is laggy as hell and behind the vegas frame counter a ... is beeing shown, as in frame 12300...
When you let the footage play shortly, pause then play it again the footage even plays normally as if it needs to buffer it before playing, its super strange. Makes me think this is an encoding problem, what i failed to mention is when i reinstalled ob i updated my graphic drivers as well.
 

Hellmann

New Member
...sry- timing is bad, maybe a mod can add this all together i hope, the footage renders normal as well, i just hope someone can still help me out.
 

rockbottom

Active Member
That looks to be upstream of OBS. You're still running Windows 7?

You can update to Windows 10 for free if your W7 is the retail version.
 

rockbottom

Active Member
Create a Scene for each Game Capture. Having 4 in 1 scene isn't a good idea. I keep all my Scenes to only 1 or 2 sources.
 

Hellmann

New Member
Ok. i guess i´ll try that- that tip with windows is good too thanks^^ I dont really know anything about scenes, didnt know what they were for so i was keeping away from it-

Also what i forgot to mention is the video file turned out to be huge like 169 gb for a 30 minute recording- usually those dont reach 20.
I am using cqp on 1080p on a cq level of 5 but even when i recorded a last week released game on highest settings that file didnt even reach 13gb, that kinda baffled me, was a pain to edit with 16 gb ram believe me XD but it rendered alright surprisingly, that file ended up normal 16 gb.
 

rockbottom

Active Member
The files will be huge with CQ set at 5. Try 18 or 19 & work from there.

Check back after you clean up the Scenes & record something.
 

rockbottom

Active Member
I just did a 1 minute encode on my 1660 Super with the CQ @ 5, it's just under 500MB. CQP is variable so file sizes will vary depending on many factors but I think your 1660 ti was just flipping out when you got that 169GB file. Once we get you straightened out, you should be back to 15GB +/- for a 30 minute recording @ 5.
 

Hellmann

New Member
I mean like i said it rendered fine, thank god XD i feel like it has something to do with certain visual filters some games run, to make the visuals look more grainy- 2 of the games where i was getting this weird problem, were using them.
While editing it my ram usage from the pc was on full 100% the playback in vegas needed like 5-10 seconds buffering time on forwards and reverts, and cause i had to censor like 5 minutes of full on naked women monsters assaulting me, sometimes having to do it frame by frame because of all the movement and way i chose to censor it for comedic value-
Believe me it took me a whole day^^ and i ended up only doing like 3 then opting for the fullscreen unsharpening to save myself XD.
Just check for yourself, its in the intro first 15 seconds- https://m.youtube.com/watch?v=fhejfl4DXXU&t=981s
editing that footage legit ruined nudity for me lmao
Also sorry for typos and or formatting, i wrote this from my phone real fast^^
 

Hellmann

New Member
The scene tip i think fixxed the problem entirely, i dont understand how, but i just created a new scene and then did a 20 minute recording of the new mount and blade and that recording is A-OK, no distort no unworldly filesize, 5 gb in all- thank you so much dude, youre awesome.
 

Hellmann

New Member
Nah not yet, transfering all the files i want to save before the drive wipe always used to be a pain- and honestly im still not sure if i even really want to use win10 at all, i might install it just to get the free update and register my key to win 10, but really i dont like the worksurface of win 10 and the forced automatic updates, i used to read every other month there is a windows update that used to break shit for other programs.
When i visit my mothers place and she asks me stuff about her laptop or if can help her with shit on her laptop with win 10 on it, i never used to be able to find or do anything, and im not a professional it guy but im somewhat knowledgable- its so unnecessarily convoluted or simplyfied, i cant even tell, i just cant deal with it and it seems unnecessary to have to try and get used to it when win 7 is just fine and i have no isses with it.
The only reason i switched to win7 from xp a few years ago is because they had released alot of games and programs that xp couldnt run ^^
 

koala

Active Member
Definitely do use Windows 10. It is more stable, occupies less disk space, in most things faster (display capture for OBS, for example, which is practically unusable under Windows 7), is supported, gets development for, and the work surface is a thing you can become accustomed to. Even I reverted from Classic Shell to the native Windows 10 start menu some time ago.
The forced updates are a good thing, because they educate you to exercise best practice with managing your system, so the overall stability improves. You cannot get away with just fiddling enough to make it work somehow. Instead you have to do it right to make it work right.
 
Top